
Order Your North Shore Thanksgiving Pie Before It Sells Out
November 16, 2026
If you want a homemade-quality pie on your Thanksgiving table this year, now is the time to check local ordering options. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, 2026, and bakeries and restaurants across Newburyport and the broader North Shore are preparing seasonal desserts. Ordering deadlines vary by business, so securing your preferred pie and pickup time early is a smart move.
Why You Should Order Your North Shore Thanksgiving Pie Before It Sells Out
Local bakeries often prepare holiday desserts in limited quantities. Unlike large grocery chains, smaller operations may have fewer available pickup slots and a more limited selection of flavors.
Some businesses require advance payment, while others have their own ordering and cancellation policies. Confirming those details when you order helps avoid surprises during Thanksgiving week.
If you're hosting this year, consider ordering dessert early in your meal planning. That gives you time to compare flavors, check pickup availability, and make alternate arrangements if your first choice is unavailable.
Where to Look on the North Shore
North Shore Magazine has published roundups of bakeries and specialty shops offering Thanksgiving desserts north of Boston. Its November 2026 coverage also highlights local farms and bakeries preparing holiday foods.
For Newburyport specifically, several businesses are worth checking:
• The Cormorant, 228 Merrimac Street: Its 2026 Thanksgiving dessert menu includes apple, pumpkin, pecan, chocolate cream, and cherry almond pies. Listed prices range from $35 to $40, with pickup scheduled for Wednesday, November 25, between 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. Check its online ordering page for availability.
• Hodgies Too, 251 Low Street: Offers Thanksgiving ice cream pies in flavors such as pumpkin, apple, chocolate, and peanut butter. Its online ordering menu lists pickup dates from November 21 through November 25. These are frozen desserts rather than traditional baked pies, making them an alternative for families who prefer ice cream.
• Chococoa Baking Company, 50 Water Street: Known for its signature whoopie pies, Chococoa is advertising Thanksgiving whoopies, pies, and other treats on its official website. Check directly for current selections, ordering arrangements, and pickup times.
• Buttermilk Baking Company, 9 Liberty Street: An established Newburyport bakery recognized for scratch-made pies and seasonal desserts. Contact the bakery to confirm its 2026 Thanksgiving menu and ordering availability.
A few practical notes on pickup: choose a date that matches the bakery's published schedule rather than assuming Tuesday is available. The Cormorant, for example, specifies Wednesday, November 25, for its Thanksgiving dessert orders. Allow extra time for holiday errands and confirm parking arrangements before heading downtown.
What This Means For You
• Thanksgiving pre-order deadlines vary by bakery. Check current availability now rather than relying on a general November cutoff.
• Ask about ingredients and allergens before ordering. Gluten-free or nut-free options should never be assumed, especially when cross-contact is a concern.
• Save your order confirmation and verify the pickup date, time, and location.
• If your first choice is unavailable, consider another Newburyport bakery, a nearby North Shore business, or a different dessert option.
Thanksgiving in this part of Essex County has its own rhythm. The Will Run for Pie 5K and Newburyport Maudslay Turkey Trot are coming together for a Thanksgiving morning event at Maudslay State Park on November 26, giving residents another local tradition to enjoy before the holiday meal.
Explore what daily life is actually like in Newburyport.
Your Questions, Answered
Frequently Asked Questions
When do North Shore bakeries stop taking Thanksgiving pie orders?
There is no universal deadline for Thanksgiving pie orders across the North Shore. Some bakeries close their order lists several days before Thanksgiving, while others stop accepting orders once they reach capacity. Contact your preferred bakery directly for its confirmed 2026 cutoff and current availability.
Can I walk in and buy a pie the day before Thanksgiving instead of pre-ordering?
Some bakeries and specialty food shops may have desserts available for walk-in purchases, but availability is not guaranteed. If you need a particular flavor, size, or dietary option, placing an advance order is the more reliable choice. Check directly with the business before making a special trip.
What is the best pickup day for Thanksgiving pies in Newburyport?
The best pickup day depends on the business and its holiday schedule. The Cormorant lists Wednesday, November 25, for Thanksgiving dessert pickup, while Hodgies Too lists pickup dates from November 21 through November 25 for its Thanksgiving ice cream pies. Choose a confirmed pickup window that fits your schedule and follow the business's storage instructions.
Sources
- North Shore Magazine — Where to Shop Local for Thanksgiving Dinnernshoremag.com
- The Cormorant — Online Orderingorder.toasttab.com
- Hodgies Too — Online Orderingorder.toasttab.com
- Chococoa Baking Companychococoabaking.com
- North Shore Magazine — Best of the North Shore: Pienshoremag.com
Keep Reading
Related reading
Watch the Short Version
Order Your North Shore Thanksgiving Pie Before It Sells Out
Homes for Sale
Live MLS listings in the areas this article covers
Keep Reading
Suggested Blogs

New Homeowner
Your Complete Guide to Unpacking After Moving to the North Shore, MA
Moving to Newburyport, Amesbury, or anywhere on Massachusetts' North Shore? Our 7-step unpacking guide helps new homeowners settle in quickly and stress-free.

General
National Housing Headwinds vs. Greater Newburyport's Market Strength
When national housing analysts sound the alarm, local expertise becomes essential — here's how Greater Newburyport compares to national trends.

Buyer
Massachusetts Home Inspection Red Flags
Don't let hidden problems turn your dream home into a nightmare. Know what to look for in the Bay State — especially in Greater Newburyport's unique coastal market.
Ready to Make Your Next Move?
Our proven process and local expertise are here to help you navigate every step of your real estate journey.